What I Wish I Knew Before My First Airbnb Guest Checked In

This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps keep Pioneer & Hearth going.

I always knew I liked hosting people. I love getting our home ready for guests — preparing the fancy bedding, styling the space, and adding all the little extra touches that make a visitor feel truly welcome. Making everything perfect. But here's what nobody tells you: hosting strangers is a completely different experience from hosting friends and family. The stakes are higher, the expectations are unpredictable, and the learning curve is real.

If you're new here, good day! My name is Sam and I am an Airbnb Superhost with properties in the great states of Maryland and West Virginia. Here are the things I wish someone had told me before my very first guest checked in.

 

Guests Will Judge Your Property — And That's Okay

In the first 5 minutes, guests decide whether your Airbnb is worth 5 stars. Regardless of how hard you clean or scrub or maintain your property, guests will judge it and compare it — sometimes to unattainable standards.

 

 

Always remember that even the Great Wall of China had a one-star review once. Accidents happen and some guests can be very unforgiving. Nicks and scratches will happen. We once had a damaged staircase at one of our properties from what we assumed was a roller bag being dragged up rather than carried. In a pinch between quick turnovers, you might not have time to fix everything before the next guest arrives. You cannot please all the people all the time. Your job as a host is to please some of the people most of the time.

Prepare for Hair. Lots of It.

I wish I had walked into this knowing how much hair would be left behind after every single stay. No matter how clean your guests seem, there will be hair. Brief your cleaners, put it on the checklist, prepare your cleaners with the right tools and never be surprised by it again. By the way don't forget to grab my Airbnb Hiring & Operations Playbook which helps you to hire the right cleaners in the first place!

Watch What Decor You Leave Out

I kept a decorative candle out once because it looked nice — and a guest lit it. Nothing happened, thankfully, but it made me realize that even something as innocent as a decorative candle could be a serious liability. In my Airbnb and Vacation Rental Welcome Basket Ideas post I touch on things that I no longer add to our Airbnbs. Audit your space through the eyes of a curious, unsupervised stranger before every listing goes live.

Say Yes to Pets Earlier Than You Think

We waited too long to open our properties to pets, and it cost us bookings. I was emotionally invested in keeping the carpet pristine rather than thinking like a business owner. Pet-friendly listings command higher nightly rates and fill gaps in your calendar. The wear and tear is manageable — the lost revenue is not. (Pro tip: stock up on the overlooked essentials that make pet-friendly hosting a lot less stressful.)

Get the Right Tools from Day One

 

I wish I had known about Hospitable and Pricelabs from the jump. Hospitable automates your guest messaging and keeps communication consistent across properties. Pricelabs handles dynamic pricing so you're never leaving money on the table. Both tools pay for themselves quickly — don't wait until you're overwhelmed to set them up.

Pricing Is Dynamic — Set It and Forget It Won't Work

Static pricing means you're likely overpriced during slow periods and underpriced during peak ones. Local events, holidays, and seasonal demand swings can dramatically affect what guests are willing to pay. A dynamic pricing tool like Pricelabs works around the clock so you don't have to — and it's one of the fastest ways to increase your revenue without adding more properties.

Your Listing Photos Make or Break Your Bookings

Guests are scrolling fast. Bright, well-composed photos of every room stop the scroll — your listing description doesn't even get read if the photos don't land first. You don't necessarily need a professional photographer, but you do need good lighting and a styled, tidy space. This is one of the highest-return investments you can make as a new host. Once your photos are dialed in, make sure your listing copy is doing the same heavy lifting.

Build Relationships with Nearby Hosts

From day one, get to know the other Airbnb hosts in your area. These relationships go a long way — they become friendships, referral networks, and a support system when something goes sideways at 11pm on a Friday. Local hosts are often your best resource for vendor recommendations, pricing benchmarks, and honest advice.

Never Change Something You Haven't Tested Yourself

Before making any major structural or property change, test it yourself first. We learned this the hard way with a water well issue at one of our properties — what seemed like a straightforward upgrade created unexpected problems for guests. Stay overnight in your own listing periodically. You'll catch things no checklist ever will.

Check-In and Check-Out Times Are Negotiable

Most guests treat check-in and check-out times as suggestions rather than rules. Learn to use this to your advantage — offering early check-in or late checkout as a paid add-on is a simple, low-effort way to generate side income on bookings you already have. It adds up faster than you'd think. We use a website called The Host Co. for this.

You Don't Always Need Airbnb or VRBO

I wish I had known from day one that I didn't necessarily need to rely solely on Airbnb or VRBO. Building a direct booking presence — even a simple website — lets you capture repeat guests without paying platform fees. It takes time to build, but starting early means you're not starting from scratch later. We use Hospitable as well for our direct booking website.

Reviews Are a Two-Way Street

Leaving timely, thoughtful reviews for your guests encourages them to review you back — and that early review momentum is everything when you're just starting out. A listing with no reviews is a hard sell no matter how beautiful the space. Make it a habit to review every guest promptly after checkout, and don't be shy about politely reminding guests that their feedback means the world to a new host.

Your Cleaning Checklist Is Everything

Instruct your cleaners to visually check under every bed as a matter of routine — it should be on the checklist, not left to memory. And while I'm a seasoned corporate recruiter, I still learned the hard way: never hire a cleaner just because they're "nice" or someone referred them. Vet your cleaners like you'd vet any key hire. I explain this method thoroughly in my operations playbook.

Scammers, Sneaky Guests, and Telemarketers Are Real

Nobody warns you about the volume of scam inquiries and telemarketer outreach that comes with listing on a platform. And beyond that, some guests will try to sneak in more people than they booked for. Stayfi has helped us monitor unauthorized guests through WiFi access — it's a tool worth looking into early.

A Guidebook Will Save Your Sanity

A detailed digital guidebook will prevent you from being on call constantly or answering the same questions over and over. Cover everything — check-in instructions, local recommendations, appliance how-tos, house rules. Let the guidebook do the talking so you can focus on growing your hosting business. A thoughtful welcome basket pairs perfectly with a great guidebook to set the tone from the moment guests arrive.

Hosting Gives You More Than Income

This one surprised me most. Hosting brings genuine joy — the connections, the stories, the satisfaction of creating a space people love. The income is great, but it's the experience of being a host that keeps you going. If you're on the fence about starting, consider this your sign. And if you haven't joined Airbnb yet, use my referral link to get started — it supports this blog at no cost to you.

Tax Obligations Will Sneak Up on You

Short-term rental taxes — occupancy tax, state and local lodging taxes — catch a lot of new hosts completely off guard. Airbnb collects and remits some of these on your behalf depending on your location, but not always all of them. Consult a local accountant familiar with short-term rentals before your first guest checks in, not after.

You Might Also Like

Shop My Airbnb Hosting Essentials: Everything I Use & Love, Broken Down by Room — the exact products I use to keep guests happy and reviews glowing.
The First 5 Minutes: How Guests Decide Whether Your Airbnb Is Worth 5 Stars — what guests notice the moment they walk in the door.
Airbnb Turnover Checklist: What to Do Between Every Guest Stay — the exact process I follow before every single check-in.
25 Most Overlooked Airbnb Essentials Every Host Needs — the items most hosts forget until a guest points it out.
Airbnb Host Emergency Kit: The Supplies That Save Every Last-Minute Turnover — the backup supplies every host needs on hand before something goes wrong.

Found this post helpful? Save it to Pinterest so you can reference it later!

Save to Pinterest